What Makes the Harry Potter Movies Age Appropriate?

Hello all! I wanted to update you that after this blog post I will be taking a one month hiatus to enjoy the winter break. I will also be switching to posting every other Friday.

I hope you all have a wonderful Christmas Holiday, and I look forward to getting back into the blog zone in a few weeks!

The following is a short essay on how the middle grade movie “Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone” and the young adult movie “Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire” are appropriate for their age groups through differences in the character dynamics, and Harry’s agency and the support given to him.

Firstly, looking at the character dynamics, we see major differences in the way the characters interact in the two movies.

In the first movie, Harry is completely new to the wizarding world and he “falls into” friendship with Hermione and Ron. 

Their friendship is a childlike one of support and exploration. The problems Ron and Harry have with Hermione are soon overcome when they save her from the troll, and she sticks up for them with the professors. 

However, in the fourth movie we see the added dynamics of jealousy and romantic interest. Ron is jealous of Harry, thinking Harry put his name in the goblet of fire. This can be seen in Ron not even wanting to talk to Harry. He instead uses Hermione to inform Harry that Hagrid is looking for him. 

The idea of romantic interest is added with Harry and Choe, and Hermione, Krum, and Ron. We see Harry for the first time being interested in a girl, which is introduced on the train sequence when he goes to get something from the trolley. He sees her and forgets himself, sitting back down and becoming rather daydreamy. 

With Hermione and Krum, Ron adds an especially interesting dynamic. Ron, who at first was obsessed with Krum because of the Quidditch world cup, quickly switches to resenting him. Although Ron’s resentment could be chalked up to not liking Hermione "fraternizing with the enemy” as he so nicely put it, it is likely much deeper than that. It seems Ron has taken his friendship with Hermione for granted and does not realize his true feelings for her. 

This romantic interest and jealousy in The Goblet of Fire is clearly a young adult theme that is a far cry from the innocent exploratory friendship in The Sorcerer’s Stone.

Secondly, we see a huge difference in Harry’s agency and the support given to him between the two movies. 

In the first movie, Harry is guided into the Wizarding world. He is shepherded by those around him by people such as Hagrid, Dumbledore, Professor McGonagall, and even Hermione and Ron. This is a middle grade theme, focusing on guidance from a parent figure. 

In the fourth movie, Harry is still assisted by those around him but they are more so in a supportive role rather than a leadership role. This contrast can especially be seen in the final scenes of each movie. 

In The Sorcerer's Stone, Harry faces Voldemort, but he is a weak and struggling Voldemort. Harry is more so facing Quirrell. And Harry is protected and saved by his mother’s love. 

In The Goblet of Fire, Harry sees Cedric die in front of his eyes. He is bound to the statue and witnesses the horrid growth of Voldemort. Then, he must actually face Voldemort. He must find the courage to face death. Although he is again assisted by others through the Prior Incantato, he still must be the one to fight Voldemort and get himself home. 

In the first movie, Harry is protected and guided by parental figures, which strongly contrasts the fourth movie where Harry must face Voldemort and save himself.

The two Harry Potter movies differ for their respective age groups through the difference in friendship dynamics, exploration, and guidance.

#28

5 Dec 2025